Comment 9 by Scott Wallace [E-Mail]
Actually, I do think it is a crisis, in this sense--we are starting to see real world effects of the lack of civic literacy, and these effects are not going to lead to anything good. The time to solve this problem is now, before it gets really out of hand and becomes a real crisis, of the civil disorder kind. So it is a crisis in the way anti-communism was in a crisis in 1979--the time to act had come before extremis was truly reached.
Exhibit A is the MoveOn attack on General Petraeus. The Founders, steeped as they were in the stories of the old Roman Republic, understood far better than many today seem to do that if you politicize the military, then after that the military is politicized. It becomes a special interest group with its own agenda, and with a certain felicity for being able to impose its will. There is a reason why George Washington loved Addison's Cato so much. Well, it may have inspired him to behave correctly, but we should never forget that the real Cato the Younger didn't have a happy ending.
Exhibit B is the growing criminalization of politics, as seen in numerous examples (Gonzalez "scandal", Plame "leak" investigation). Exhibit C is the growing politicization of crime by ambitious prosecutors (Nifong, Spitzer, et al). Exhibit D are things such as the Kelo v. New London eminent domain case, where citizens are slowly becoming subjects. Exhibit E is the behaviour of the United States Congress, with its gerrymandered safe districts (feudal realms) and penchant for pork.
I think all these things have common root causal factors--1.) a lack of an intuitive understanding of civics; 2.) lack of knowledge of the bounds of legitimate conflict and conduct in politics (or lack of belief that there are any bounds); and 3.) lack of an awareness of the bigger picture concerning the mutual relationships between government, society, and individual.
Having already lost whatever knowledge of civics they may have had, today's pols and politicos can only judge their actions by polls, ballots, and what the MSM will allow. Nothing deeper.
And I think it is a crisis because if you read enough history, you see that sometimes it really only takes 20-30 years or so for a societal change to take hold, and then there is no going back. And how long has this been brewing? This society is operating on inertia. But friction eventually slows down all things unless more energy is added.
If we don't act now, then the heavy lifting needed ten-20 years from now to reinculcate the spirit of Americanism may be more than we can achieve. Nations change, and people change, and not always for the better. Latifundia, anybody? A college education used to provide that knowledge because you learned enough ancient and medieval history and politics/philosophy for the lesson to take home. No longer.
